IRQ plan + validation matrix: the login-based QEMU proofs (PS/2 + serio,
monotonic timer, IOMMU first-use, USB storage BOT) now run through
local/scripts/qemu-login-expect.py (stdlib python) instead of the host expect
tool. MSI-X (virtio-net) and xHCI interrupt-driven mode were re-confirmed on
the current redbear-mini ISO. Re-confirmation of the login-based legs with the
new harness is pending an uncontended host (parallel QEMU workload kills QEMU
processes and stalls guest boots). Also record the fbcond Performing-handoff
boot freeze observed with -vga std (separate graphics-path issue).
Correct the P3-A runtime-validation note and matrix row: the
intermittent apparent boot freeze is startup latency under load (guest
clock ~10-15x slower than wall), not a deadlock or an xhcid bug. A short
50-60s test timeout occasionally cuts the spawn+enumerate sequence,
producing a 'frozen' log while the guest is still running — proven by
18 boots (one apparent short-timeout loss), a 12s log-quiet 'freeze'
the guest resumed from, and every >=180s run enumerating fully. No fix
required beyond adequate test timeouts; no speculative kernel-deadlock
fix was implemented.
The usb-kbd behind the QEMU usb-hub now enumerates fully: debounce ->
port reset -> enable -> second debounce -> pre-attach -> attach ->
ATTACH 5.2 -> slot 3 -> addressed -> descriptors read -> HID class match
-> 'Loading subdriver "USB HID" for port 5.2' (class 3.1 proto 1,
keyboard boot protocol).
Root cause of the final stall: an unconditional SetPortFeature
(PORT_INDICATOR) for every connected+enabled port NAK-hung on QEMU's
indicator-less hub (no control-transfer timeout), blocking the flow
before the post-enable debounce. Now gated on
wHubCharacteristics.HUB_CHAR_PORTIND like Linux has_indicators.
test-usb-hub-qemu.sh: check #5 now requires the hub-child subdriver
line ('Loading subdriver "USB HID" for port <root>.<child>') so a
root-port HID (tablet) can no longer satisfy it — closes a false-
positive hole. Timeout raised to 360s for slow TT-path driver bring-up.
Docs (plan P3-A runtime validation + matrix): full hub + hub-child
chain recorded as QEMU-proven; remaining items (intermittent reactor
startup race, slow TT-path Evaluate Context) noted.
USB-IMPLEMENTATION-PLAN.md P3-A: record the 2026-07-19 QEMU runtime
validation (test-usb-hub-qemu.sh) — full usbhubd chain proven
(descriptor, EP1 change detection, initial scan, debounce, reset to
port-enable), the five latent bugs it surfaced and that were fixed
(scheme attach bootstrap, bitmap off-by-one, missing initial scan,
unbounded EP1 wait, debounce clear deadlock), QEMU's ClearPortFeature
stall handled gracefully by P2-C recovery, and the remaining gap:
hub-child device enumeration (usb-kbd to HID driver) blocked on
xhcid's hub-child attach path (debug-level; TT/route investigation)
plus an intermittent xhcid IRQ-reactor startup race.
HARDWARE-VALIDATION-MATRIX.md: hub row to QEMU-validated for the
enumeration chain, with the hub-child gap noted.
Track base pointer to bd379e07 (usbhubd debounce/reset-wait/U0-wait/
wHubDelay + SET_ISOCH_DELAY, HubDescriptorV3 device_removable fix).
USB-IMPLEMENTATION-PLAN.md: P3-A marked CORE COMPLETE with the full
Linux equivalence inventory and documented follow-ups (USB 2.0 bitmaps,
SS.Inactive warm-reset loop, multi-TT, hub LPM). Hub gap-table row
updated (249 -> ~700 LoC with Linux state machine).
HARDWARE-VALIDATION-MATRIX.md: hub row updated — enumeration core
complete with 14 unit tests; runtime hub proof tracked under P8-B.
- udev-shim: replace .expect() with graceful errors (no more panic on Broken pipe)
- P4-initfs: remove duplicate sessiond (conflicted with config)
- accessibility/ime/keymapd: break instead of exit(1) on EBADF
- P6 driver patches rebased
- Docs: archive old reports, add implementation master plan
vasilito